I currently have a guilty-pleasure television show. I’ve seen the episodes on Netflix at least twice apiece, and I look forward to the latest episodes with great anticipation each week.
It’s not a crime drama (networks have beaten that genre, which I never liked anyway, to the ground). It’s not a sitcom (nothing can hold a candle to the classics). It’s not Big Brother (I can’t even . . .).
It’s the Great British Baking Show.
STOP LAUGHING. It’s a delightful program, and I have noticed many parallels to the writing journey within it.
–The judges, Paul Hollywood and Mary Berry (I’m not making that up—those are their real names), are tough but fair. If a cake is undercooked, Paul will point it out. Mary will call out a pie with a “soggy bottom.”
Good editors will also be tough but fair, pointing out underdeveloped plots, problems with flow, and tiny technical errors that creep through. At the end of the day, they’re doing their job to make our writing better. Don’t we all want that?
Like Paul and Mary, editors are also free with praise when they find something they like. Getting a handshake from Paul when he tastes something good is the ultimate compliment. Mary is fond of branding certain treats as “scrummy.” It’s a happy moment when an editor truly likes something we have written.
Now, if an editor starts complaining about a soggy bottom, that’s another story . . . but I have received comments about my “saggy middle.”
–The contestants help each other. This one fascinates me. Even though it is a competition with big stakes, the bakers on the show are generally nice, everyday people who regularly come to each other’s rescue. They are quick to offer a word of encouragement or a gentle hug to each other when needed.
Shouldn’t we, as writers, be that way? Sure, we might be competing for the same readers, but we are all in this thing together. I could not make it without the support of my fellow writers, who cheer me on and even cheer me up when I need it most. I know if I needed someone to lend a helping hand with my leaning multi-flavored eclair tower, a writer friend would jump right in there.
–The contestants’ individuality comes through at every step. Even in the technical round, when the competitors have to bake the exact same thing from limited directions, each person’s final product is unique. One of my favorite contestants, Frances, was often criticized for her fanciful bakes, decorated to the hilt according to thoughtful, creative themes each time out. Other contestants go for a simpler approach, with limited extras.
God made each of us writers to be unique, with a voice all our own. Some of us write fancy, exquisite prose, while others prefer to keep it simple. I can’t write like you anymore than you can write like me—and would we really want to do that?
–Hosts Mel and Sue provide comic relief amidst the tension of competition. Their puns and funny asides keep the show rolling in a breezy, enjoyable manner. The two funny ladies prove to be a perfect foil for the serious judges, and their banter often puts the nervous contestants at ease.
What more can I say? Don’t we need some humor in our writing? Even if you’re dealing with serious subject matter, lightening up now and then can help your readers. I know, I know, I lighten up all the time, but that’s who I am.
Even with all of these similarities with the Great British Baking Show and the writing process, there is one noticeable difference: I don’t think anyone reading this blog writes in a big ol’ white tent on the grounds of a pristine estate in the British countryside. But, hey, it could happen.
Maybe I’ll head out to the tent to write something . . . and to enjoy a scrummy snack.
17 Comments
Oh,my! I love this show, too. Fascinated with the varied ways ingredients come together to create masterpieces for the eye and tastebuds. Though, I can’t vouch for the health quality of recipes with so much sugar and white flour, but when there’s a cuppa tea to be had, the goodies on this show are just the ticket to complement. Terrific comparison to editor and writer tribes. Sweet!
Joy!
Kathy
Thanks for reading and for your kind comments! Yes, they do some different things on that show, but the finished results always look so good.
I like the baking show too! There are a lot of similarities with the writing journey. I can’t decide which is better–a yummy chocolate cake or realizing an article I’ve written has been accepted for publication! Good column!
Thanks, Jeris! I always go for chocolate first . . . but publication is cool, too! 🙂
I never miss an episode! Did you hear—it’s the last season for this cast? ?
The comparison you’ve made is brilliant! Thanks for the encouragement.
Thanks for the kind words! And, yes, I’ve heard about the cast changes. It’s sad, because they all flow so well together.
What a fantastic comparison! One of the aspects of being a Christian writer that I love the most is in the way we all keep each other lifted up and are eager to help each other. You’re right on the nail with that one! Thanks for this. 🙂
Thanks! And, yes, we have to lift each other up.
I love this analogy and I enjoy watching the show as well. It’s funny how writers discover these nuggets in what we watch.
I’ve often compared the business side of writing with the show, “Shark Tank.” We have to know our market, express our commitment to the project, and convey why someone else would want to invest their time and money into it.
So true! And thanks for reading and commenting.
“I know if I needed someone to lend a helping hand with my leaning multi-flavored eclair tower, a writer friend would jump right in there.”
You know Connie and I would be right there to help with that one : )
Good article as always and you always bring a smile…
Thanks! Yes, you and Connie would have my back . . . and my macaroons! 😉
I’ve never seen the show, but I might have to do just that now that I’ve read your article. Great analogy … simile … comparison … thingee.
You definitely need to watch it! And thanks!
Great comparison here! I may just have to check it out on Netflix too!
Ha! I too love cooking shows, and relating food to writing and vice versa. Good job.
“I can’t write like you anymore than you can write like me—and would we really want to do that?” I love this. It’s so easy to try to be like someone else, but the only way we’re going to be successful is if we find our own voice. I also enjoy that show and your comparisons were spot on!